Scottish Gemmological association


upcoming sga evening meetingS

Tuesday, September 24th, 7.00 FOR 7.30pm

Ian Bone of Jewels of Queensland and Capricorn Gems, speaking on Ethical Mining of Australian Gemstones.

For more info, click here

Wednesday, October 30th

Marco Campos Venuti, speaking on Agates

Wednesday, November 27th

Elizabeth Passmore, speaking on Andrew Grima

Jewels by Andrew Grima, illustrated by the style, gemstones and stories of some of his creations.

upcoming sga symposium

Timed to coincide with the Elements Jewellery and Silversmithing Fair at Lyon and Turnbull which runs from Friday 8th November to Sunday 10th November.

saturday, November 9th

SGA Gemmological Symposium
in the Hepburn Suite
at The Royal Scot Club
29-31 Abercromby Pl, Edinburgh EH3 6QE

There will be Speakers and Presentations on various gemmological topics

From 9.30am. to 4pm. allowing delegates to then visit the excellent Elements Jewellery and Silversmithing Fair held in Lyon and Turnbull’s premises at 33 Broughton Place, should they wish!

The Incorporation of Goldsmiths are also organising an evening event at Lyon and Turnbull after the Exhibtion closes for the day.

Delegate charges for the Symposium only, to include a light lunch and refreshments, will be £40 with discounted prices for SGA Members and Students of £20 each.

Click here for more information and booking form.

upcoming sga afternoon event

Saturday, 23rd of November

We are planning an outing to Malcolm Appleby’s Studio Workshop and Christmas Shop at Grandtully By Aberfeldy. More details shortly, but if you are interested, please email on :

Annual General Meeting

The Annual General Meeting of the Scottish Gemmological Association took place at 7.30pm. on Wednesday, 4th September, 2019 in the Eric Liddell Centre, 15 Morningside Rd, Edinburgh EH10 4DP. Directions -

After the AGM there was a very well received talk from Charles Evans:-

Swat Valley Emeralds: The Beauty and the Beast.

The challenges of verifying a supply chain in order to secure opportunities for the amazing product of an incredible region for a brave new brand.

Notice of AGM
AGM Agenda
SGA Constitution
Duties of Committee Members
Committee Member Nomination Form

2018 AGM Minutes

2018 Profit and Loss / Balance Sheet

2018 Chairman’s Report

GemSet 2019

Jewellery Design Competition

We are delighted to announce that the judging panel made the following awards:

1st Prize

Madeleine Kline City of Glasgow College

2nd Prize

John Green Glasgow School of Art Continuing Education

3rd Prize

Bingyan Qu Edinburgh College of Art

Highly Commended

(listed in no particular order)

Rad Pieknok City of Glasgow College

Anna McFadyen Glasgow Kelvin College

Richard Gillingan Glasgow Kelvin College

Emma Brouwer Glasgow Kelvin College

Valentina Boneva Glasgow Kelvin College

For all the images, click here -

Madeline Kliine 1st.JPG

upcoming sga evening meetingS

Our post summer meetings dates will be announced shortly.

Stuart Robertson-Cigdem Lule Student Sponsorship 2019

This year’s award has been made to Rebecca Bohle who is currently studying for her Gem-A Foundation Qualification while working at Bonhams in Edinburgh.

We look forward to welcoming Rebecca to this year’s Conference.


Alan Hodgkinson - Gem Testing Techniques

Alan has sold the last available copy of his wonderful book Gem Testing Techniques. 

He has said that there may, at some point in the future, be a second printing,  however there is nothing planned at present.


Past meetings and events

Tuesday, 4th June, 2019

at the Lyon and Turnbull’s Auction Rooms, 33 Broughton Pl, Edinburgh.

We were invited to a preview of Lyon and Turnbull’s upcoming Jewellery, Watches and Silver

On Tuesday, 26th March, 2019

Miranda Wells presented us with an excellent talk on The History of Diamond Cutting and the Development of the Modern Round Brilliant. This was followed by the opportunity to handle examples of the diamonds she had been talking about.

All who attended greatly appreciated the knowledge she shared and the opportunity to study examples and we hope to see her again in the not too distant future!

On Thursday, 28th February, 2019

Trevor Kyle of Lyon and Turnbull delivered a lively and entertaining talk entitled Discoveries and Anecdotes of an Auctioneer and, between stories on his life as an auctioneer, Trevor took a look at various items brought along by our members, some quite curious - -

We also had a selection of books from the late Tom Watson’s collection offered for sale and afterwards we had our uusual post meeting supper. A very enjoyable evening!

 On Wednesday, 23rd January, 2019

Alan Hodgkinson hosted presentations from a selection of our jewellery fabricating members, which offered a unique opportunity to get behind pieces of jewellery and understand the origin of the design and the skills involved in their production. 

Those taking part with Alan include Joanna Thomson, Gillian O'Brien, Lesley Skinner and Xanthe O'Connor.

The SGA Christmas Dinner

was held on Tuesday, 4th December at the Salisbury Arms on Edinburgh’s Dalkeith Road.

This year the SGA Committee awarded the Catriona Orr McInnes Award to Jilly Pollard in recognition of her many years of dedication to gemmology in Scotland. Alan Hodgkinson was delighted to present the award before we dined.

Wednesday 21st November

Shirley Mitchell delivered an entertaining talk on Variations in Gemstone Valuations, and there was the opportunity afterwards to examine several of the items highlighted during the talk.

shirley talk sm.jpg

The Whitby Trip

Over the weekend starting Friday 28th September, a group of us went to Whitby and then on to Castleton.  We were lucky with the weather!

Also we greatly appreciated the time we were able to spend with Sarah and David Steele at Ebor Jet Works and the Whitby Lapidary Museum and with Rebecca Tucker and Chris Sellors, first at the new Museum of Jet in Whitby, at the W Hamond shop and then at the C W Sellors head office in Ashbourne. Our sincere thanks to them all for their involvement in making our trip such a success.

group pic whitby.jpg

For more photos, click here -,

Wednesday 31st October

Adam McIntosh of Two Skies (Edinburgh) on The Adventures (and Misadventures) of a Rockhunter.

Another highly enjoyable event, with the added advantage that that, when he is not off on his travels, Adam can be found in his Royal Mile shop for those who need another fix!

Thursday 27th September

Our first evening event for 2018 / 19, Cigdem Lule’s talk on Coated Gemstones was thouroughly appreciated by all who attended!

Scottish Gemmological conference, 2018

This year's Conference at the Westerwood Hotel in Dullatur near Cumbernauld has been described as a 'resounding success'.  Denitsa Popova who won the Robertson / Lule Scholarship this year has written a report which can be found here -

wednesday, 28th march, 2018

The final talk arranged before our Conference was from Clare Blatherwick on the 28th of March entitled World Tastes in Jewellery.

Clare looked at some of the factors that drive the global market, what sort of stones, makers and eras are commanding the greatest interest, with examples of prices achieved in auctions across the world, as well as opening up a discussion on predictions for 2018.


wednesday, 28th February, 2018

Alan Hodgkinson starting with his observations from Tucson 2018 and finishing with an exploratory glimpse into a bequest received from Eric Bruton.

One of the highlights of Alan's recent trip to Tucson was attending the evening event which announced that the University of Arizona is creating a new Chair of Gemology at the University which will collaborate with the Gem-A in this new venture by the university into the world of gemology.

alistir, charles and alan.jpg

On January 18th we were delighted to have Charles Evans from the Gem-A come to visit us.  He described his talk as 'a whistle-stop journey through the Kimberley region,  before concluding with a visit to the depths of some of the oldest mines in the region'..   A pfd that accompanied his talk will appear shortly.


In December we had no meeting scheduled, instead we gathered at the Salisbury Arms in Edinburgh on Tuesday the 12th for a pre-Christmas dinner celebration. And a very enjoyable time was had by all!



29th November:  Stuart Pool on Responsibly-sourced Gemstone,  7.00 for 7.30 p.m

This highly informative talk was about the mine-to-market journey of the gemstones of Sri Lanka, highlighting the artisanal mining and also covered the range of stones that are found there. 

For those who missed it this time round, there will another opportunity to hear Stuart in 2018 at our Conference, so we are not including a pdf of his presentation!



8th November:   Maria Maclennan  on Forensic Jewellery

Maria pic 1 final.jpg

We were delighted to have Maria join us for the evening when she explained just how her career path had progressed to her current employment and interest in the development of the evolving field of Forensic Jewellery.   We were also treated to some actual case studies which illustrated this interesting subject. 

Our sincere thanks to Maria for a very enjoyable talk and our best wishes that her enthusiasm and energy carry her forward along this fascinating path.


18th October:   Marcus McCallum on Included Quartz and other Gemmological Curiosities

We were delighted to see Marcus back in our midst, with some really unusual specimens for us to look at, together with a selection of his stock.  A good time was had by all!




27th September:  Richard Taylor was speaking on Colour Perception Testing, a pdf outlining his presentation is below.

Richard gave us a very enjoyable and informative talk and he braved the rather erratic wifi available to us with humour and perseverance!  Our sincere thanks.

"How well do colour communication systems work within the context of the gem and jewellery industries?

A recurring challenge within the jewellery and gem industries is how to reliably communicate colour and the development of a methodology to measure and/or quantify colour in a reliable and reproducible manner that has meaning and relevance to the human condition. Historically colour communication has relied upon the use of descriptive names but over time the meanings can change and if value and profit becomes involved the temptation to expand or alter a ‘colours’ boundaries for personal gain is created.

Colour communication therefore creates an interesting challenge and a moral dilemma for the gem and jewellery industries, with many failed attempts attesting to the challenging nature of the problem. The difficulty some may find strange is not our ability to measure colour accurately, this is easily achieved using modern scientific instruments, it’s the fact the way humans ‘see’ colour is fundamentally different to scientific measurements therefore the value measured frequently does not relate or correspond to the colour we ‘see’. This complexity is further expanded when considering that the ‘colour’ of a gemstone can be a complex combination of varying hues tones and saturations,  from which the ‘apparent’ endeavour in colour communication is to select a single colour to best represent this perceived complex image."

For pdf of presentation, click here -

Following on from this talk, Richard is looking for some assistance with his ongoing research and would be happy to discuss it further with anyone interested.  Richard's research is based on gemstones, however it has a much wider relevance and could be of interest to anyone involved in the Arts and Design disciplines.


On the 30th of August we had a very informative workshop with Andrew Fellows of Birmingham City University.

"So you think you know your diamonds from your cubic zirconias and synthetic moissanites?  From glass through to bismuth germinate, there are far more diamond simulants both on the market today and historically than many people realise.  With a chance to see a range of these natural and synthetic stones up close, this evening looks at the timeline for these simulants, and offers advice on testing procedures, and how to differentiate them from true diamonds"

Andrew gave a short presentation and then turned us loose on the various and wide ranging examples of simulants her had brought along.  There was even a very large CZ - 80mm. in diameter, 50mm in depth and weighing in at 3176ct!   As ever with Andrew, we had a really enjoyable time and we are very grateful for his efforts on our behalf.  We were also very happy to welcome his parents to our event.

A pdf of his presentation notes for this workshop can be found here -

2017 Annual General Meeting

Our AGM was held on the 9th of August, at the Eric Liddell Centre.   We had several apologies from members unable to attend and the result was maybe a slightly smaller attendance than previous years, but a still very select group!   Minutes will be issued in due course.  Chairman's Report

This was followed by a very informative presentation by Carmen Garcia-Carballido on her recent trip to Australia.   Judging by the photos and enthusiastic tales told by Carmen, she and her husband Peter had a truly memorable time visiting areas of Australia renowned for opal and sapphire production and meeting with several fascinating miners and characters along the way.  She hopes this was the first trip of many!

Carmen also brought to the meeting a variety of samples of rough and finished material which she acquired on her journey.  After the talk, we had an enjoyable time examining these.

Our sincere thanks and appreciation go to Carmen and to her husband Peter for his assistance.

carmen opal talk3crop.jpg


lauriston Castle Outing

We had a very enjoyable afternoon out at Lauriston Castle.  Our guide Mike did an excellent job of showing us the interiors and telling the history, not only of the castle itself, but also of some of the memorable owners.  Everywhere we turned, there was something else to see - another visit might be called for!

Some photos to whet your appetite:


SGA award to BCU Gemmology and Jewellery Studies Degree graduating Student

On the the 13th of June, Birmingham City University hosted an Industry Evening and also made awards to individual students. Within the Jewellery Department, an award was presented to the graduating Gemmology and Jewellery Studies Degree student with the highest marks, Delyth du Plooy.

The prize, a place to attend the 2018 Scottish Gemmological Association Conference, was donated by the SGA. Alistir Tait, our Chairman, attended the event and seems to have enjoyed himself!




2017 Conference Photos

There are a selection of photos now available to view, just click here -


GemSet Competition 2017

This year's 1st Prize was awarded to Monika Nemanyte of Glasgow City College,  for her hand made mixed metal, enamelled and gemset pendant.

  To see the full list of those who received awards and photos of their submissions, please click here -


Happy Birthday Alan!

On Wednesday 22nd March we had an early surprise celebration of our President Alan Hodgkinson's 80th Birthday.  Cake and fizz enjoyed by all who were there -

Congratulations Alan!


previous MEETINgs

On Wednesday, 22nd March, we had Godfrey Fitton talking on The Natural History of Blue John.

This was a thoroughly enjoyable presentation and we are hoping to follow it up with a summer outing to Lauriston Castle.  Details will follow shortly.  Meantime, Godfrey has generously allowed us access to the Powerpoint presentation which accompanied his talk.

  More -


At February's meeting Alan Hodgkinson was our speaker for the evening and gave us the benefit of his observations and insights from this year's Tucson Show.  As always his presentation was full of detail, accompanied with interesting anecdotes and, as ever, made those who weren't in Tucson this year wish they had been!

Alan also returned with The Hanneman Trophy, awarded for Contributions to the Literature of Gemology.  Alan said he was honoured that the name Hodgkinson would be following in the footsteps of previous recipients including:  Anderson, Webster, Liddicoate, Sinkankas, Pough, Arern, Bruton, Gubelin, Nassau and Koivula.

Our congratulations to Alan!

alan h with Hannerman trophy1.jpg


Idar-Oberstein cutting

On the 25th January 2017, we were delighted to have Deborah Mazza talking on Idar-Oberstein cutting.  As always, she showed great knowledge and enthusiasm for her subject.

 Deborah discussed gem carving as an art form and also considered the question of skill/craftsmanship vs talent.  Gem carving has been developed to a very high standard due to modern technology and particularly to the skill of Idar-Oberstein artists.

 We were treated to an excellent presentation, mainly concentrating on three of the Idar- Oberstein cutters she has in-depth knowledge of and regards highly.  To give a flavour of the content of her talk to those not able to attend, this link is to a video of Manfred Wild, one of the cutter she chose to discuss.

There were also some examples of Idar-Oberstein craftsmanship available to view and handle.



Our November meeting was a presentation from Sarah Steele of Ebor Jet Works in Whitby. 

Sarah's enthusiasm, knowledge and experience came shining through and we were treated to an evening packed full of information, images and examples of related (and not so related!), materials, both in rough form and as finished pieces.

Our thanks to Sarah for the time and energy she put into this presentation and we look forward to hearing about her next exploits.



Scottish Sapphires

Our October meeting was a highly enjoyable talk given by Ian Combe on Scottish Sapphires. The meeting was well attended, as was our meal afterwards, and we all greatly appreciated Ian's efforts on our behalf.  After recounting stories of his (and that of a few of our other members!) involvement with Scottish Sapphires we had the opportunity for a closer look at several cut stones, some rough and some finished jewellery.

 We do have a couple of photos and this PDF originally printed by The Times (we think!) in 1995.

This PDF of Ian's presentation gives an outline of what he covered for those who were unable to attend.



Jade Talk and Workshop.

On Wednesday 28th September, Andrew Fellows presented us with a workshop on Jade.  Andrew is well known within British Gemmology circles and is a regular attendee at our Conferences.  He is a professional gemmologist, diamond-grader and ODL Tuition Manager at Gem-A in London.

jade talk people1.JPG

After a short talk on the sources and different kinds of jade, we were able to handle and look closely at a selection of specimens from Andrew's personal collection.  Our sincere thanks to Andrew for making the trip north to talk to us and we look forward to his next visit!

Our 'after meeting' suppers are getting popular.  We had 16 attendees for our visit to Cafe Grande and there have been positive reports!

For those who were unable to attend the actual meeting, Andrew has generously given permission for us to include a pdf of the illustrations for his talk.  To view, click here -


Burma Trip

As many will be aware, last year several of our more intrepid members undertook a Gemmological Trip to Myanmar, or Burma as we often still call it.

For photos, please click here




Postal Address

Please send all correspondence to:

The Scottish Gemmological Association

c/o Alistir Wood Tait

116A Rose Street



Email address